Friday, December 04, 2009

"The collective assemblage is always like a murmur from which I take my proper name, the constellation of voices, concordant or not, from which I draw my voice.... To write is perhaps to bring this assemblage of the unconscious to the light of day, to select the whispering voices, to gather the tribes and secret idioms from which I extract something I call my self."
- Gilles Deleuze and Claire Parnet, Dialogues, pp. 84.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, June 19, 2008

particularism and conceptions of passion

For old Samoan society, in which a daughter’s marriage was an important route to social ascent, the idea of mating for reasons of personal sentiment had dangerous implications. We have seen that the sexual independence of lower-status girls was tolerated, as long as they acted in the status interests of their families. A danger in this sexual system had long been acknowledged: the girl’s inner feelings might become so strong in relation to an inappropriate (low-status) sexual partner that she would elope, gainsaying her parents and other relatives (avaga i le loto o le teine). In Samoan the word loto refers to private thoughts and personal feelings. The phrase momo i loto means “inner yearning” or “inner longing” and is used to describe the feelings of a girl who runs off with a boy and is brought home but then runs off again. In these cases friends may counsel parents that there is nothing they can do. Clearly, passion for a specific individual in sexual relations is not confined to Euro-Americans cultures. But in old Samoa this phenomenon was viewed as something of a hurricane, a misfortune in the face of which resignation was appropriate. It was not cultivated.
- Mageo, Jeannette Marie. 1996. “Spirit Girls and Marines: Possession and Ethnopsychiatry as Historical Discourse in Samoa.” American Ethnologist 23(1):61-82.

Labels: ,

Thursday, June 12, 2008

The Tragedy of the Cowboy

Frontier keynotes in [Frederick Jackson] Turner's landmark essay of 1893 associate the availability of free land on the western frontier with such supposedly "American" character traits as inquisitiveness, inventiveness, practicality, independence, diligence, restlessness, and exuberance. Similarly, in post-1925 media portrayals of the frontier we find a tough, exuberant, honest, and independent character, the outlaw, who is pitted against the forces of social order. These civilizing forces represent dependence/interdependence, comfort, dishonesty, and weakness, although paradoxically or tragically they are fated to win the struggle. (161)

Adams, Paul C. 1997. "Cyberspaces and Virtual Places." Geographical Review 87(2): 155-171.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, May 13, 2008

on name-related puns

… only through a consideration of the dialectic of freedom acting under given material conditions can the concrete reality of a man’s life be grasped. [Sartre] shows a particular freedom at grips with destiny, at first apparently crushed and suffocated by fatedness, later eroding this fatedness piece by piece. If Genet is a genius, then his genius is not a God- or gene-given gift, but an issue invented by Genet alone, in particular moments of despair. He seeks to rediscover the choice which Genet makes of himself, his life, and the meaning of the world, to become a writer, and to show how the unique specificity of this choice pervades even the interstices of the formal character of Genet’s style, the structure of his images, and the particularity of his tastes.

- R. D. Laing and D. G. Cooper, Reason & Violence: A Decade of Sartre’s Philosophy, 1950 - 1960, pg 67.

Labels: ,

on Genet's negotiation of possession

… Genet is ‘faulty’ not only from the point of view of being, but also from that of having. … Nothing could belong to him, material possession was forbidden him, all his life had to be a continued effort to dematerialize objects and construct their metaphysical doubles, which alone he could possess.

- R. D. Laing and D. G. Cooper, Reason & Violence: A Decade of Sartre’s Philosophy, 1950 - 1960, pg 70.

Labels: ,

on Genet's plight-as-orphan

Certainly [Genet] was born of a woman, but this physical origin was not retained in the collective memory. He came into the world from an unknown womb, almost as an article produced by a modern factory bears no trace of the human producer. Belonging originally to an administrative apparatus, his later affinities tended to be for institutions -- the reformatory and the prison.

- R. D. Laing and D. G. Cooper, Reason & Violence: A Decade of Sartre’s Philosophy, 1950 - 1960, pg 68.

Labels: ,

on Genet's belief in inequality in love

The essence of the loved one is his indifference, his profound nature of being a thing, an object. Genet conceives of the couple as the union of body and spirit, but this relation is not reciprocal, since consciousness may be consciousness of body, but body is quite simply body, body is completely itself. The body in itself (en soi) is an autonomous substance; consciousness is in itself and for itself a relation. It is this autonomy of substance that Genet calls indifference. All the words he uses to designate the loved are negations or disguised negations -- for example, ‘immobile and silent’, ‘inflexible’, ‘impenetrable’, ‘the angel of death itself, as unyielding as a rock’. The loved one is absent, or present only as an appearance. His purest virtues are his destructive forces and his lack of positive qualities. In the moment of submission Genet reduces the male to a shadow, an appearance of being which exists only through Genet. This is the principal source of Genet’s treachery.
The loved male is above all the No: non-life, non-love, non-presence, non-good.

- - R. D. Laing and D. G. Cooper, Reason & Violence: A Decade of Sartre’s Philosophy, 1950 - 1960, pg 82.

Labels: , ,

Sunday, May 11, 2008

on Genet's creation of self

What can I decide to be if I am already what I am: if I am ‘locked up in my being’? The word ‘being’ for Genet assumes an active, positive value, and in the phrase ‘J’ai decide d’etre ce que le crime a fait de moi’, to be is to throw oneself into one’s being in order to coincide with it.

- R. D. Laing and D. G. Cooper - Reason & Violence: A Decade of Sartre’s Philosophy: 1950 - 1960, pg. 75.

Labels: , ,

on Jean Genet's theiving (to make sense of the world)

After this destruction another destructive act follows in the conversion of the value of a object from a use value to a value of exchange. Theft results, thus, in the radical destruction of the stolen object, the disorganization of the values of usefulness and sentimental association, an impoverishment of the world. Our acts sketch our form on being, the created object present its creator to himself in an objective dimension. In creation I am really exteriorized amongst beings in the world: in destruction the universe is reabsorbed into me.

- R. D. Laing and D. G. Cooper, Reason & Violence: A Decade of Sartre’s Philosophy, 1950 - 1960, pg 89.

Labels: ,

on suspending disbelief

The sway of alcohol over mankind is unquestionably due to its power to stimulate the mystical faculties of human nature, usually crushed to earth by the cold facts and dry criticisms of the sober hour. Sobriety diminishes, discriminates and says no; drunkenness expands, unites, and says yes. It is in fact the great exciter of the Yes function in man. It brings its votary from the chill periphery of things to the radiant core. It makes him for the moment one with truth. Not through mere perversity do men run after it…. It is part of the deeper mystery and tragedy of life that whiffs and gleams of something that we immediately recognize as excellent should be vouchsafed to so many of us only in the fleeting earlier phases of what in its totality is so degrading a poisoning. The drunken consciousness is one bit of the mystic consciousness, and our total opinion of it must find its place in our opinion of that larger whole.

- William James, The Varieties of Religious Experience, Lectures XVI & XVII: MYSTICISM, pg. 257.

Labels: , , ,

Friday, April 25, 2008

The Looping Effect and Expectations

Times change, and so do people. People in trouble are not more constant than anyone else. But there is more to the change in the lifestyle of multiples than the passage of time. We tend to behave in ways that are expected of us, especially by authority figures -- doctors, for example. Some physicians had multiples among their patients in the 1840s, but their picture of the disorder was very different from the one that is common in the 1990s. The doctors’ vision was different because the patients were different; but the patients were different because the doctors’ expectations were different. That is an example of a very general phenomenon: the looping effect of human kinds. People classified in certain ways tend to conform or grow into the ways they are described; but they also evolve in their own ways, so that the classifications and descriptions have to be constantly revised.

- Hacking, I. 1995. Pg 21. Rewriting the Soul: Multiple Personality and the Science of Memory. Princeton: Princeton University Press

Labels: ,

on authenticity and categorizations

To begin with, the question “It is real?” is not of itself a clear one. The classic examination of the word “real” is due to the doyen of ordinary language philosophers, J. L. Austin. As he insisted, you have to ask, “A real what?” Moreover, “a definite sense attaches to the assertion that something is real, a real such-and-such, only in the light of a specific way in which it might be, or might have been not real.” Something may fail to be real cream because the butterfat content is too low, or because it is synthetic creamer. A man may not be a real constable because he is impersonating a police officer, or because he has not yet been sworn in, or because he is a military policeman, not a civil one. A painting may fail to be a real Constable because it is a forgery, or because it is a copy, or because it is an honest work by one of John Constable’s students, or simply because it is an inferior work of the master. The moral is, if you ask, “Is it real?” you must supply a noun. You have to ask, “Is it a real N?” (or, “Is it real N?”). Then you have to indicate how it might fail to be a real N, “a real N as opposed to what?” Even that is no guarantee that a question about what’s real will make sense. Even with a noun and an alternative, we may not have a real anything: there is no such thing as the “real” color of a deep-sea fish.

- Hacking, I. 1995. Pg 11. Rewriting the Soul: Multiple Personality and the Science of Memory. Princeton: Princeton University Press

Labels: , ,

the social sciences in competition

The psychotherapist seeks to intervene; the anthropologist wishes to observe and to interfere as little as possible in the lives of the people she is studying.

- Erika Bourguignon, pg. 374, "Multiple personality, possession trance, and the psychic unity of mankind," Ethos vol. 17, issue 3, 1989

Labels: ,

on sensitivity (not)

Humanitarianism is found only in a small minority of highly sensitive people…. Such humanitarianism is too easily confused with a somewhat different sentiment, that of prudence…. But it is one thing to condemn pornographic films because they are immoral and sully the viewer’s soul; it is quite another to condemn them because they turn the human persons who are their actors into objects.
[Gladiators] … aroused ambivalent feelings, both attraction and a prudent repulsion. On the one hand there was the taste for watching people suffer, the fascination with death, the pleasure of seeing corpses; on the other hand there was the anguish of seeing that within the very confines of public order it was legal to murder not only enemies or criminals but others as well. Society no longer provided a bulwark against the law of the jungle.

- pg. 148, “Foucault Revolutionizes History” - Paul Veyne, transl. Catherine Porter - 1978

Labels: , ,

on technology and weakening

As their telescope and microscopes, their tapes and radios become more sensitive, individuals become blinder, more hard of hearing, less responsive.

- Martin Heidegger, Dawn and Decline: Notes 1926-1931 and 1950-1969, pg 162

Labels: ,

on spreading behavior

The history of [female bulimia] suggests that, in a mass society such as that of the United States, various widespread disorders may exist “underground” as long as they do not catch the public eye, so that when they are “discovered” they constitute an epidemic, a national problem, a newsworthy event. This is related to the way in which news is produced, as well as to the manner in which pathological behaviors of individuals, given appropriate publicity, can serve as models for other.

- Erika Bourguignon, pg. 373 "Multiple personality, possession trance, and the psychic unity of mankind," Ethos vol. 17, issue 3, 1989

Labels: ,

Saturday, April 19, 2008

more reification

It also presents the most sophisticated Marxist case for considering an object free of its systematic attachments:
It is only infatuation (with the object contemplated), the unjust disregard for the claims of every existing thing, that does justice to what exists…. The existent’s one-sidedness is comprehended as its being, and reconciled. (76)
Adorno’s praise for the “sabbath eyes… that save in their object something of the calm of the day of its creation” (76) is beautiful. But it is also influenced, indeed fatally compromised, by the existentialism that he elsewhere denounces. To speak of toy trains climbing free of the exchange-value system and its compulsions is to posit that the linguistic system, and the taxonomic ordering of the world, are cognate with a system of political oppression-- a system from which escape is possible. Similarly, in most modernist writing, there remains an assumption that objects are able somehow to gain “freedom” from systematic classification, just as the autonomous human in existentialist accounts is said to rise clear of an obligatory world to gain a life in the moment of choice. In such accounts, the negative space from which a three-dimensional animate object springs erect -- is either ignored or (systematically) trivialized to the point of nonexistence.


- John Plotz, “Objects of Abjection: The Animation of Difference in Jean Genet’s Novels,” 103, Twentieth Century Literature, Vol. 44, No. 1, (Spring 1998)

Labels: , ,

toys, like klee

…Adorno’s Minima Moralia ascribes a splendid life to children’s toys only insofar as they step out of the system of exchange-values and return to a purely purposeless use-value.
The little trucks travel nowhere and the tiny barrels on them are empty; yet they remain true to their destiny by not performing, not participating in the process of abstraction that levels down that destiny, but instead abides as allegories of what they are specifically for.

- John Plotz, pg 228, “Objects of Abjection: The Animation of Difference in Jean Genet’s Novels,” 103, Twentieth Century Literature, Vol. 44, No. 1, (Spring 1998)

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, April 09, 2008

on time, stasis, revolution

Revolutionary time finally marks our escape from prison time into a full mode of living, unforeseeable, exposed, open to desire. This mode of living is at all times constituent of our new, revolutionary time. Prison time, however, will always return as soon as that revolutionary time is closed down, as soon as rebels allow the revolt to congeal, as soon as a constituted power is erected. We do not break out of prison once and then remain free; our alternative existence must be a continuous project in perpetual motion. Revolutionary time is a never-ending means without an end. Any end would destroy it.

- Michael Hardt - "Prison time," Yale French Studies Vol. 91, 1997, pg 78

Labels: ,

on history (diffuse)

History is thus now recognized as the chaos of a multitude of desires become coherent, temporarily in constituent groups, patterns, or movements -- in a procession of encounters. This constituent history, in contrast to a constituted history, is the extended elaboration of the ceremonials that animate the time of Genet's writing.

- Michael Hardt - "Prison time," Yale French Studies Vol. 91, 1997, pg 77

Labels: ,